The following is a completely unedited post written by my 12 year old son. The snark is aimed at a very obnoxious commenter that has been critical of our choice to be part of the System.
A Post By Derech Eretz
Hey – would you find it interesting if I wrote a post about this whole foster care thing from my perspective? Really? Ok. Then I will.
I'll take you through this in words you can understand. I have read through these comments, and while some are helpful and written by bright people, others are hateful and written by the dimmest bulbs in the box. I'll try to compromise my writing for the dimmer bulbs.
I was on my bus two weeks ago coming home from camp. I was tired. Pooped – if you will. I had also gotten two bee stings. (My friend and I had been attacked by bees that day). The way my bus route is mapped out, my bus passes my house going on the opposite side of the road. I live on a county road, so my bus cannot just turn into my driveway if it's going on the opposite side of the road. I saw my mom, Tikkun Olam, talking on the phone in our doorway. That had me wondering. We don't usually receive calls at that time. I know that would usually be a crazy thought. I am a child. Children are curious. Well anyway, my bus dropped of some more people and turned around to drop me off. I got home and my mom was still on the phone. She was saying something about age, if I remember correctly. Soon after that she got off of the phone and told us that we had just gotten a placement! I was shocked. It was time to prepare. I started to clear out CD's room of junk and I rested. If you don't think that's a necessary part of preparing for a new sibling after a very long day of camp, you are wrong. Remember? Pooped? So I rested.
My dad got home and we needed to go to K-Mart to pick up the basics for CD. That means sippy-cups, diapers, clothing, etc. We then proceeded to go to our friends who had a crib that they were just about to sell. I must include that it is a very nice crib. We went home and guess who was there? CD! It's like first seeing your sibling. I know because I remember seeing my little brother for the first time. That, I believe, is my first memory. I was only 3½.
CD was very scared of my dad. She was scared of me too, but at that point, she was much too tired to care. I had her in my lap and she couldn't see me so she was fine.
My dad, brother and I went to set up CD's crib. We had no A/C in her room. We half-assembled the crib when we decided it was too hot in there so we temporarily moved it to my parents' room. It's nice and cool in there.
That was pretty much the end of my day and I fell asleep. I dreamt some and then I woke up in the morning. I got up. I took a shower. I got dressed. I did what I do every day. I ate breakfast. Something on this day was different, though, because I wanted to see my sister. Yes, I am calling her my sister because we're supposed to treat her like family and to me she is family as long as she needs to be. I was extremely tired because of how late I had stayed awake the night before. After that, I just could not fall asleep. So I stayed home from camp. We went to Target. I pushed CD in the shopping cart and held her as she would be distracted by all of the pretty things in the store. We went home. That's all I really remember from that day because I was half-asleep the whole day.
Those were the first two days that I knew CD. Since then she has warmed up to me and my dad and has been so friendly. Do you think your stereotypes of foster children are correct? If so, then you're WRONG. She couldn't be any sweeter or more well behaved. She feels like a sister to me.
That weekend we went to my aunt and uncle's house to get all of their hand-me-downs. My aunt buys the most beautiful clothing for her children, so CD was in luck. We had a lot of fun there.
I could go on and on about my everyday experiences with CD, but that would take me forever to write, and you've already read my mom's posts. You probably want to hear my opinion on this whole foster care thing. Well here it is.
I'm making foster care my Bar Mitzvah project. That shows just how much I care for these children whose parents can't take care of them for whatever reason. This cause is really important to my whole family. I'll have more about that in future posts.
Now CD is sick and is very difficult to take care of. Last night she kept waking up and crying every half hour or so. She was waking me up too. I fell asleep, but CD and my parents didn't much. They've been tired all day and taken only short naps. CD is now sound asleep and happy. She's getting better. I hope she continues to be better.
As I continue to grow, I see life's purpose more clearly, and that is to leave the world better than when you found it. This, foster care, in our case, is making the world better. What is better than teaching someone how to fish. If you give a man a fish, he'll have dinner for one night. If you teach a man how to fish, he'll have dinner forever.
Criticize me all you want. Seriously. Go on, tell me why this is wrong. I will surely answer to your comment. Say all you want, don't censor yourself because I'm just a kid. Go on, comment your words of wisdom.
From Mr. Mister, my 8 year-old son: Today my mom’s parents came to my house. After my dad and I went to the library, it was closed. So then we went to Target we got CD clothes and looked for the game Stratego. When we got home my dad and I played Stratego. It was a busy day.
23 comments:
Amazing post!
I'm not sure who's more awesome, the mom or the son ;)
I'm sorry you've been getting haters. I recommend deleting any comment that even hints at disrespect. Make life as difficult as possible for trolls.
Very well written. If I didn't know better, I'd have thought it was written by someone far older and more mature. But, I do know better, so I'm surprised at all.
You're all doing a great thing. Ignore those who wish to disparage you, you'll never satisfy them. Keep up the good work!
Derech Eretz is a perfect nickname for you! CD is so blessed to have "fallen" into this loving home where it's so obvious children are raised to be thoughtful, loving, and caring individuals. I love your mom's blog and I'm happy she gave us the opportunity to meet you. I'm very interested in knowing more about your Bar Mitzvah project and I hope you will share more...
In the words of Little Tommy Callahan from "Tommy Boy" (a movie you should really watch one day if you haven't already) - "I swear I've seen a lot of stuff in my life, but that... was...awesome."
That WAS awesome. TO, you are an amazing mom with an amazing kid. You should be so proud! I am blown away by the love and sweetness in this post. And I think making foster care his bar mitzvah project is excellent. More families need to welcome children who need homes.
Beautiful.
Another tear-jerker.
I almost can't read this blog without tearing up...
Major Kudos to the whole family :)
Not only has foster parenting been an amazing journey as I see the foster children grow in love...its been also amazing to see my children grow in character. It looks like the same has been happening in your home. thanks for the good read and the perspective. CD is blessed to have all of you.
Ditto to all the comments. Very moving post and CD is lucky to have you as a foster big brother!
Thanks all. I am sure D.E. will write again. Now my little guy is working on a post.
Thanks again for all the moral support. Its been a rough few weeks and the people in our lives, who are able to focus on the big picture, remind me over and over why we are doing this.
Tik - you are an awesome mom. it is just so obvious in the words of your son - he takes his cues from you and his dad, and what wonderful cues they are.
HSM, think he got the snark part from me though :)
Mr. Mister - Save that Stratego game. When you start dating in 13-14 years you can play it.
Couldn't agree more with all the compliments above. Kiddo, you're quite an amazing big brother. And you've got the makings of a great blogger in your future. You've got just the right amount of snark in your post! :0
LK - I'm really sorry about what happened to your child in foster care, but haven't you realized yet that my family would never do anything to hurt anyone???
>> Don't believe everything they tell you. It just isn't true.
Well, then. Maybe you're not understanding our situation. Why would anybody lie to be evil like that??? I assure you no information has been jumbled on the way to me.
>> Why? Children are the products of their environments. It's not your fault.
Not my fault, huh? It is your fault. You're the only one here that believes that we're doing something completely wrong. I doubt that I did anything wrong for it to be my fault.
>> You've only been told one side of the story.
Perhaps you fail to understand our side of the story. I truly believe that you need to get our side of the story.
>> I really have nothing against your mommy.
Hmm... Really??? 'Foster Shrink, Meal Ticket, etc...'
Your "JOB" as discouraging families of being a foster family has no good reason. That one bad thing that happened to your child does not happen around here. I want you to realize that.
Ok, good enough for you? BTW - I most definitely did not write this post for you, nor did my mom ask me to.
Everyone Else -
Thank you for the beautiful comments. I will definitely write again.
LK, I am not going to publish further comments from you.
You underestimate my son. He didn't need permission to read your blog. He read it. Your experiences are relavent to you but not to my work or our current care of CD. It is irrelavent. Like any bigot who becomes an antisemite because has been cheated by one Jew or a racist if mugged by one Black man and generalized to all Black people you are doing the same.
When you have a family who does a good job, when you have a prof in the system who is fighting to make it better, writes reports for judges sometimes advocating for immediate reunification (not often) and has made calls over and over to report institutional abuse you are simply picking a fight with the wrong person. Hate does not make the world a better place. It helps no one. Hate does not belong on this blog. Your hate is truly misdirected here. There is no conversation to be had. In your mind I will continue to be a "system suck" while in my mind we are helping a children and in prof life, helping many children. In my mind you are a bigot, irrational and so consumed by hate that your experience makes you unable to have a rational conversation. While this may be fun to you it is juvenile to me.
So goodbye. I am sad for you but your abusive tone is not welcome here. My son is happy to keep responding to you but he doesn't deserve your completely absurd condescending tone.
What a great post, you must have inherited your mother's great writing genes! I second your Uncle C's comment, that was awesome (thanks for the shout out about the nice clothing btw, it's our pleasure to share it all with CD).
I don't know, when I was 12 years old all I cared about was whether Mickey Mantle would hit a home run in the next game. Now we have 12-year-olds commenting on such weighty issues as foster care, bigotry, mental health, etc.
I have always believed that our rabbis were wrong in asserting one of the fundamental propositions of Orthodox Judaism, that is, that every generation is inferior to the one that preceded it. I believe that to be false whether it is applied to the study of Torah, science or human relations. This essay by D.E. unequivocably proves my point. What comfort it is that the future of mankind will be in the very capable hands of D.E. and his friends. May his family continue to have much nachas from him and his siblings.
Please note: I deleted LK's last comment. It was such a beautiful comment thread I just felt it unnecessary to muddy it up by one individual's truly obnoxious comments. DE's comment is in response to his.
LK, If you don't like our family, why do you read our blog?
Derech Eretz, you are simply put: MADE OF AWESOME.
Inspired by your rejection of her posts, I went to see the LK (legally Kidnapped) blog.
I think that there are several interesting themes that could be discussed out of the tension field between LK and your blog.
For one part, it is true that it is not always possible to find a devoted foster family as you seem to be. It has happened, that "foster carreers" do not really go smooth. This would be an interesting topic to discuss. Since you are a professional working in the field, you might be able to show studies and figures that show how high the precentage of unsuccessfull foster careers is vs. successful fostering.
Secondly, it is also interesting to give attention to the point of view of the abusive or neglecting parents themselves. Allthough they might be unfit for parenting, it might happen that they do not think so, subjectively. Here too: you are a professional in the field, why do you not give us some data and figures to put this aspect into perspective.
And, it might truely happen that child protection services are misdirected in some cases and investigate the "lighter" cases while turning a blind eye to the more severe cases. Here also, an objective point of view from a professional, based on research, would be very welcome for the readers.
All in all, I think there are other methods than censorship to answer interventions like LK's. Perhaps it would afford more work, but it would definitely leave a better impression with the readers.
European/LK
Firstly, European, I also rejected one of your comments due to its hostile nature. To respond to your Q though, this is not my son's blog. He runs 2 of his own related to activities he is involved in. I did not choose to censor his post or comments but I chose what I did want to censor. In other words, I get veto rights.
I am not sure that I understand what you mean by foster careers. I am a clinician and a parent, not a researcher. I can only talk what I know. Data such as what you are asking about does not really exist, especially if you really care to know how things differ from place to place, which is entirely relevant. Foster care is not the same system in my state as it was even 5 years ago. I have been around to see very swift changes when a grant funded office was created to oversee drastic changes.
What I can do is tell some of the stories of bio parents who have lost and in many cases, regained custody of their children. Of course I would do this without any identifying information or details. I can discuss the couple of cases in which I petitioned immediate reunification or immediate significant increase in visitation to not allow the attachment between child and parent to deteriorate.
I will, however, reserve the right to moderate. My favorite Dr. Philism - "you teach people how to treat you." I am not looking for a battle between blogs or even a conversation between them. LK and I cannot have a civilized conversation. She is hostile and talks at me, not to me. "System suck" does not for a productive conversation make and it is not acceptable in this forum. There are plenty of blogs that do that kind of thing. I am choosing to not have that sort of blog.
As far as my readership goes, I am pleased with my readership. I am not looking for readers who want to instigate conflict, who are attracted to conflict or are going to come here and be insulting to others. There are ways to have productive conversations and disagreements without that kind of tone.
I am not a new blogger despite the relative newness of this blog. I have enough experience to know what type of blogging is for me.
Post a Comment